In Latest Wireshark version ( 4.4) there is only 3 options of Output Audio rate in RTP player ( 16000, 44100, 48000) while there was more option in 4.0 version Please advise of the reason
Qt5 and Qt6 have different ways of handling audio devices. Qt5 audio devices (QAudioDeviceInfo), when querying, give a short list of all the hardware supported sample rates. Qt5 does not itself support resampling. To play audio, the device is queried for the list of hardware sample rates, and then Wireshark must resample it before sending it to the output.
Qt6 (QAudioDevice), unlike Qt5, supports resampling. There is no function to retrieve the hardware supported audio sample rates. You can retrieve the minimum or maximum supported sample rates, or query if a particular rate is supported, but Qt6 will attempt to support any particular rate you give it by resampling as necessary.
The current workaround is to query for a small list of commonly supported sample rates, and list the ones that are supported. It's theoretically possible that some of those are being resampled twice, once from the Wireshark resampler (from SpeexDSP) and once by Qt6. Perhaps in the long run, when Qt5 support is completely dropped, Wireshark will not perform resampling and simply rely on Qt6's implementation.
Thanks for the detailed answers! We were analyzing RTP audio at an 8k sample rate and saw that exporting to 16k in Wireshark 4.2.6 or 3.60 created artifacts that did not match the original capture.
I noticed the playback mode doesn't affect the timing of the audio in file exports, exports always go by RTP timestamps, but it does take the playback sample rate for file exports. (this was helpful in trying to figure out what to expect in the export)
Wireshark 3.60 allowed 8k sample rate selection and doesn't create audio artifacts in the export from the same Wireshark capture file. I'm thinking I should check the issue tracker if this is known, and maybe add it, but I would rather not resample the exports to begin with. I would like to see a feature that detects the original RTP sample rate ...
Changes needed to support Qt6.
Audio didn't work in 4.0.0. Qt reverted to Qt 5 in 4.0.1. Moved to Qt 6 in 4.2.0.
The Windows installers now ship with Qt 6.2.3. They previously shipped with Qt 6.2.4.
The Windows installers now ship with Qt 5.12.2. They previously shipped with Qt 6.2.3.
The following bugs have been fixed:
Issue 18413 - RTP player do not play audio frequently on Windows builds with Qt6.
7206: Qt: Update the RTP stream UI to support Qt6Multimedia.
void RtpPlayerDialog::fillAudioRateMenu()
{
ui->outputAudioRate->blockSignals(true);
ui->outputAudioRate->clear();
ui->outputAudioRate->addItem(tr("Automatic"));
#if (QT_VERSION >= QT_VERSION_CHECK(6, 0, 0))
// XXX QAudioDevice doesn't provide supportedSampleRates(). Fake it with
// what's available.
Version 4.0.17 (v4.0.17-0-g882448bcf104). Compiled (64-bit) using Microsoft Visual Studio 2022 (VC++ 14.37, build 32822), with GLib 2.72.3, with PCRE2, with zlib 1.2.12, with Qt 5.15.2, ...
Version 4.2.0 (v4.2.0-0-g54eedfc63953). Compiled (64-bit) using Microsoft Visual Studio 2022 (VC++ 14.37, build 32822), with GLib 2.78.0, with Qt 6.5.3,
Asked: 2024-09-09 20:13:26 +0000
Seen: 134 times
Last updated: Sep 12