Decrypt TLS traffic not working

edit

I'm testing capturing HTTPS traffic and decrypting in Wireshark. So far I've not been able to successfully decrypt. The setup...

• Client is behind firewall (Watchguard)
• Firewall has HTTPS Proxy configured to inspect traffic
• Custom cert, signed by my private CA, is loaded on firewall to re-encrypt traffic after inspection
• Proxy rule is configured to not allow PFS, disabling ECDHE
• tcpdump file is generated on firewall device
• In Wireshark Preferences > RSA Keys, private key file (.PFX) is loaded (also tried loading the old way under Protocols > TLS > RSA keys list)
• Protocols > TLS configured to save TLS debug file

Using Chrome I make a single HTTPS request to postman-echo.com and capture via tcpdump on the firewall. In Chrome > Developer Tools > Security tab the encryption is reported as TLS 1.2, RSA, and AES_128_GCM. Open the .pcap in Wireshark but no TLS data is decrypted.

Packets as viewed in Wireshark link text

Debug log file link text

I believe everything is set up correctly but I can't decipher the debug file enough to determine what's wrong. Looking for some insight.

Thanks